In September 1938, a devastating hurricane battered the Atlantic Ocean, striking a ship transporting two young African giraffes to New York City. The animals survived against long odds, though the female suffered an injured leg upon arrival. Against the grim backdrop of the Great Depression, the Dust Bowl, and rising war threats in Europe, the public fixated on these gentle giants. Their twelve-day journey across the unpaved highways of America in a custom truck became a rare national sensation of wonder and hope.
Lynda Rutledge builds her historical novel West with Giraffes around this true 1938 transport of the San Diego Zoo's first giraffes. Narrated by Woodrow Wilson Nickel, a hundred-and-five-year-old veteran recording his youth before time runs out, the story follows seventeen-year-old orphan Woody as he unexpectedly lands the job driving the giraffes' rig. Paired with a gruff zookeeper called the Old Man and pursued by an ambitious photographer named Augusta Red, Woody embarks on a life-altering trek across a fragile, pre-interstate nation.
A Nation in Crisis and the Miracle of 1938
In October 1938, the United States was a battered country struggling through the prolonged misery of the Great Depression and the environmental devastation of the Dust Bowl. As news from Europe grew increasingly ominous with Adolf Hitler's expansionist threats, ordinary Americans desperately sought stories of resilience. The survival of two African giraffes who endured a devastating Atlantic hurricane struck a deep chord across the country. Their arrival in New York City became an instant media event, attracting frantic newspaper coverage as plans took shape to transport them thousands of miles west.
The destination for the pair of long-necked survivors was the San Diego Zoo in Southern California, which had never housed giraffes before. Transporting such delicate, unusually tall animals across thousands of miles required a specially outfitted rig and extreme caution. Rutledge uses this documented historical voyage as the foundation for an expansive narrative that explores how a weary public found genuine solace in creatures that represented untamed beauty and survival against overwhelming odds.
Sources: Book Review: West with Giraffes by Lynda Rutledge | Book Thoughts from Bed · West with Giraffes – by Lynda Rutledge – independent book review – (Historical Fiction: United States) – Toby A. Smith – Books & More · West With Giraffes by Lynda Rutledge | #historicalfiction #bookreview | #LakeUnionPublishing – Portobello Book Blog
Woody Nickel and the Unlikely Entourage
At the center of the story is Woodrow Wilson Nickel, a seventeen-year-old Dust Bowl orphan who fled hardship in the Texas panhandle only to lose his remaining shelter in New York to the same hurricane that brought the giraffes ashore. Through a twist of fate, Woody secures a temporary position driving the giraffes' custom vehicle. He quickly forms a deep emotional attachment to the animals, whom he affectionately observes during quiet roadside moments, snuffling and reaching out for food like onions.
Woody does not travel alone; he is supervised by a zookeeper known simply as the Old Man, or Mr. Jones. Gruff and guarded on the surface, the Old Man possesses extensive animal expertise and a profound moral reverence for living creatures. Joining their itinerary from a distance is Augusta Red, a determined young photographer trailing the truck in hopes that her snapshots of the traveling celebrities will launch her professional career. Together, this unlikely trio and their exotic cargo form a close-knit group united by a shared sense of purpose.
Sources: Book Review: West with Giraffes by Lynda Rutledge | Book Thoughts from Bed · West With Giraffes — Marmalade and Mustardseed · West With Giraffes by Lynda Rutledge – West With Giraffes Discussion Guide – LibGuides at Ramapo Catskill Library System
Navigating the Pre-Interstate Frontier
The physical setting of the novel offers a vivid portrait of late-1930s geography, long before the establishment of modern interstate highways or standardized roadside amenities. Driving across the country meant navigating dirt roads, wooden bridges, and precarious mountain switchbacks without guard rails. Heavy rains occurring a hundred miles away could spark sudden flash floods that washed out solitary routes, leaving hundreds of travelers stranded in remote areas alongside impoverished families migrating toward California in search of agricultural work.
Rutledge captures the sensory details of Depression-era travel by highlighting vintage auto courts, local motor inns, and modest roadside attractions. The custom truck, housing two tall giraffes poking their heads through high openings, presented constant logistical challenges. From maneuvering beneath low bridges to securing night shelter, the journey exposed the entourage to both the stark poverty of Hoovervilles and the spontaneous generosity of strangers fascinated by the passing parade.
Sources: Book Review: West with Giraffes by Lynda Rutledge | Book Thoughts from Bed · West with Giraffes – by Lynda Rutledge – independent book review – (Historical Fiction: United States) – Toby A. Smith – Books & More · West With Giraffes — Marmalade and Mustardseed
Photographs, Secrets, and the Perils of the Road
As the rig moves across the Lee Highway and southern backroads, the trek becomes more than a routine delivery. The giraffes are not merely gentle curiosities; their high visibility attracts shadowy figures and opportunistic schemers willing to resort to extortion or theft to acquire the valuable animals. This constant threat of sabotage creates ongoing tension throughout the twelve-day journey, forcing Woody and the Old Man to stay vigilant during nocturnal stopovers.
Simultaneously, emotional intimacy deepens among the travelers as they navigate personal secrets and past trauma. Woody falls in love with Red while grappling with his own history of neglect and displacement. Meanwhile, the Old Man imparts quiet wisdom regarding animal welfare and human empathy, instilling in Woody a lasting respect for all forms of life. The road trip transforms from a frantic drive into a formative coming-of-age experience for the young driver.
Sources: Book Review: West with Giraffes by Lynda Rutledge | Book Thoughts from Bed · West with Giraffes – by Lynda Rutledge – independent book review – (Historical Fiction: United States) – Toby A. Smith – Books & More · West With Giraffes by Lynda Rutledge | #historicalfiction #bookreview | #LakeUnionPublishing – Portobello Book Blog
Narrative Frame and Critical Scrutiny
Rutledge structures the novel as a retrospective memoir written by Woody at the age of one hundred and five while residing in a veteran care facility. This frame allows the narrative to contrast the immediate urgency of his teenage journey with the reflective clarity of extreme old age. Woody realizes that while his younger self was obsessed purely with reaching California, the true meaning of his life lay in the relationships and lessons forged along the open road.
From a critical standpoint, the novel's reliance on a centenarian narrator recalling minute dialogue and precise sequence details from nearly nine decades prior stretches plausibility. Additionally, certain added suspense subplots involving roadside antagonists feel somewhat artificial compared to the authentic historical texture of the Dust Bowl setting. Nevertheless, Rutledge succeeds in balancing historical realism with emotional warmth, delivering a compelling portrait of cross-country survival.
Sources: West With Giraffes by Lynda Rutledge | #historicalfiction #bookreview | #LakeUnionPublishing – Portobello Book Blog · West With Giraffes — Marmalade and Mustardseed · West With Giraffes by Lynda Rutledge – West With Giraffes Discussion Guide – LibGuides at Ramapo Catskill Library System
Ideas to take away
- Crisis and hardship can be mitigated by shared wonder, as shown by how weary 1938 Americans found hope in the miraculous survival and journey of two giraffes.
- Focusing solely on a final destination can obscure the personal growth and deep connections that occur during the journey itself.
- Respect for animal life requires empathy and stewardship, reflected in the Old Man's core belief that life holds value regardless of species.
- Navigating unexpected hazards requires adaptability and resilience when facing unmapped challenges, such as driving an oversized vehicle without modern highways.
Our assessment
Lynda Rutledge's West with Giraffes transforms a true 1938 historical event into a touching coming-of-age saga and portrait of Depression-era America. Through the eyes of an elderly veteran recalling his youthful cross-country drive with two rescued giraffes, the novel highlights the enduring power of compassion, interspecies bonding, and human connection during times of widespread hardship. While some dramatic subplots lean on contrived suspense, the book excels in capturing the rough reality of pre-interstate travel and the quiet dignity of caring for vulnerable creatures across a changing American landscape.
Sources and further reading
- Book Review: West with Giraffes by Lynda Rutledge | Book Thoughts from Bed
- West with Giraffes – by Lynda Rutledge – independent book review – (Historical Fiction: United States) – Toby A. Smith – Books & More
- West With Giraffes by Lynda Rutledge | #historicalfiction #bookreview | #LakeUnionPublishing – Portobello Book Blog
- West With Giraffes — Marmalade and Mustardseed
- West With Giraffes by Lynda Rutledge – West With Giraffes Discussion Guide – LibGuides at Ramapo Catskill Library System
Interested in the book? View West with Giraffes: A Novel on Amazon.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Editorial transparency: This analysis draws on the cited publisher descriptions, interviews, excerpts and independent commentary, not an independent cover-to-cover reading.
